John 9:1-41
There are days in our lives when struggles seem to fill all our time. Days when we wonder where God is, or if God really exists, or who God is. In this scripture lesson for today, we have a story about a healing, but it is also a story about people trying to figure out who Jesus is. We have a story of a man who, due to no fault of his own, finds that many in his society ostracize him, treat him as an outcast, want nothing to do with him, even ridicule him. And into the life of this man comes Jesus, bringing the truth of God into the man’s life, or maybe it is telling us how the man’s life speaks the truth about God.
This is a much longer lesson than we usually read. I want to read the whole lesson, to get the whole story. So, let’s walk through this lesson together, stopping many times to point out and talk about points in the story. Reading from the Gospel according to John, chapter 9, verses 1-41.
Read John 9:1-5. In the days that Jesus was walking this earth, some 2000+ years ago, medical knowledge was extremely limited compared to now. There was little to no knowledge of why such things as birth defects occurred. Even the term “birth defects” implies a point of view that some physical differences made a person inferior, as though they were defective. With no knowledge of why such things happened, it became a common approach that one, like the man in this story who was blind from birth, was blind as a punishment for sin. If the blindness was from sin, it seemed like the man himself could not have committed the sin before he was born, so often the parents were accused of some sin which had caused their child to be born with physical disabilities.
The disciples may just be making small talk, or asking a deeper question, when they ask Jesus who sinned, this man or his parents. Jesus answers, “Neither”. The guy was not born different as a punishment. It was not just an accident. This guy was born so that God’s works might be revealed in him. That really is the case for all of us. All of us are here so that God’s works might be revealed.
Read verses 6-12. Jesus heals this man born blind. Jesus spits on the ground, makes a bit of mud with the saliva, spreads the mud on the man’s eyes, and tells him to go and wash in the pool of Siloam. Sometimes we see Jesus healing with just a word. Sometimes we see Jesus healing when he lays his hands on someone. This time Jesus does a bit more. When the man is healed, people don’t seem to recognize him.
Sometimes that happens. Sometimes we see someone in a different situation or dressed differently than we usually see them, and we don’t recognize him. Here the neighbors can’t even agree if this is the same person. It is he. No, it is someone who looks like him. But notice they don’t ask him if he is the same person.
Read Verses 13-17. They take the man to the Pharisees. Now we are told that the healing took place on the Sabbath day. The Pharisees were very strict in their belief that all needed to strictly adhere to the law. The law said that there was no work on the Sabbath. Making the mud to put on the man’s eyes would be considered work. On the Sabbath there were restrictions about how far one could walk. You could feed the animals, but you should give them extra the day before, so not as much on the Sabbath. There was the example that if your mule fell into a well on the Sabbath, and if it was ok, and would be ok until the next day, then you it would be work to pull it out of the well, but if it was hurt and needed attention, it was ok to pull it out. So, if the guy had been blind since birth, it would be ok to wait a day before healing him. They figure that this is proof that Jesus is not sent from God. And they do not believe the man when he tells them how he was healed.
Read verses 18-23. So, they do not believe the man. This guy is treated like he is a non-entity, like he isn’t even there when people talk about him, like he doesn’t even exist. Well, they call in the parents and ask the parents about this man born blind who now can see. Now the parents know that the Pharisees had already decided that anyone who confessed Jesus to be the Messiah would be put out of the synagogue. And they knew that he was their son, and was born blind, and they did not know much else. So, what do they say? “He is of age, ask him.”
Read verses 24-34. The Pharisees call the man who had been born blind and who now sees. They call him in to be questioned a second time. They begin by saying that they know that this Jesus is a sinner. And the man replies, “I don’t know if he is a sinner, but know that I was born blind and now I see.” And he is asked again, “How did he open your eyes?” I love the answer, “I have told you already, and you would not listen. Why do you want to hear it again? Do you want to become his disciples?” And the Pharisees reply, “We know that God has spoken to Moses, but as for this man, we do not know where he comes from.” And another brilliant zinger from the man born blind who now sees, “Here is an astonishing thing! You do not know where he comes from, yet he opened my eyes. If this man were not from God, he could do nothing.” The Pharisees are insulted and drive the man out of the synagogue.
Read verses 35-41. Jesus hears that they had driven him out, and goes to find him. I think that is an amazing detail. It is as though Jesus does not like the way this man was treated and goes to talk to him, to comfort him, after the Pharisees had been so rude, so very unwelcoming, and just plain not listening to what the man said.
The Pharisees, who would have claimed to know right from wrong, what was truth about God, how to live to please God, these Pharisees were judging others without knowledge and understanding. If you don’t know what is right from wrong, it is difficult to get blame for doing the wrong thing. But, if we claim to know right from wrong, then we can be held to a higher standard.
Jesus comes here to a man who was not in the mainstream of his society. If the belief was that his blindness was the result of a punishment for sin, then his continued blindness would be a proof of his continued sin. Jesus does not buy that explanation. Jesus does not judge the ones on the fringe of society, or the ones not welcomed in society. He does not act like they do not exist. Instead, he seeks them out. He comes to them. He welcomes them. That is a welcome into the Family of God. Amen.
-Neil Lindorff