Luke 13:1-9
Today’s scripture reminds me that every sermon should come with a disclaimer: I don’t know what this means. It’s good to remind ourselves that Jesus lived 2000 years ago in a very different time and place from ours. The stories about his life were written down decades after they happened by people who weren’t eyewitnesses and who also lived in a very different time and place from ours. When we come to think about these stories, we aren’t asking so much, “What did Jesus mean?” as we’re asking, “What meaning can this hold for us?” So that’s my disclaimer. I’ll take a stab at this one and you decide if any of it hold meaning for you.
This scripture refers to a news story of the day: Pilate had ordered the murder of some Galileans, presumably while they were making sacrifices in the Temple, or perhaps during sacrifices in a Roman temple. It’s a gruesome story. People are asking why the victims deserved such treatment? What had they done wrong to be punished by God in this way? Remember the people with the question were first-century people. This was a time before significant scientific discovery and people of all religions believed there were gods in charge of all aspects of life who micromanaged events according to some godly principle or perhaps some godly whim. The question is why would the Galileans’ God, who was also Jesus’ God, let this happen?
Jesus is clear that he sees the story behind this story differently. He’s not interested in why these folks deserved such horrible treatment, but he is interested in everyone, including those who came with the question, living in a different way. Repent means to turn around and live differently. Unless you repent, you will die like they did. Unless your change, the world won’t change.
We sometimes hear this same question when disasters come in our time. We could name a lot of disasters: the destruction of 9/11, numerous wars, catastrophic storms, plane crashes. Why does God let these things happen? Do you remember after Hurricane Katrina when some preachers declared God was punishing the riotous lifestyle of New Orleans by storm? They thought they were quoting Jesus, but here Jesus is clearly saying, “Don’t worry about what they did wrong; look at yourselves and how you’re living.” Disaster is perhaps a reminder that life is fragile, and we choose every day to value living. Or not.
Jesus doesn’t seem to me to be interested in placing blame or explaining God’s control of the world. I’m tempted to say God didn’t appear to be in control of the world in the first century, or for that matter the twenty-first century. There were and are daily disasters. If God would fix them, why aren’t they fixed? Is God allowing disaster as punishment? Many of the victims seem innocent of crime and undeserving of capital punishment by violence. Or perhaps we can say right out loud that God is not micromanaging Life. That what happens to us for good or ill is not the direct cause of God choosing our life story for us. The events of our lives are not the will or the whim of God.
Then what good is God? I’m convinced that God permeates every part of the fabric of Life. But what benefit do we get from that if God isn’t intervening on our behalf and we’re still subject to illness and tragedy? If God isn’t bringing us good, what good is God? Here are three gifts of God which matter to me in the face of the horrors of life on earth: vision, grief, and inspiration.
Let’s start with vision. Jesus was convinced that God has a vision for what life can be that’s quite different from the way humans have chosen to live it throughout history. The prophet Micah spoke that vision aloud and Jesus knew his words well: Do justice, love kindness, walk humbly with God. Follow that vision and the world is a better place. It’s a good summary of Jesus’ own teaching, inviting people to repent or turn around in their behavior and live in just and caring communities. There are millions of people who have claimed to live by Jesus’ teaching across the centuries, and a few of them actually practiced his vision. Just because it isn’t widely implemented doesn’t mean it can’t give us hope. I choose to believe that justice, kindness and humble community are still possible, and we’d all do better if we lived by those principles.
Second, I believe God gives us the gift of God’s own grief at the traumas and tragedies of life. If God holds a vision for goodness, then surely God grieves as much as we do when people hurt, life is ended, and the earth and communities are torn. Sometimes when the unspeakable happens we just need someone to agree that the only response is grief. We need someone to share our sadness and to join in our tears. We need a companion to walk with us when our world falls apart and to give us time and space for healing. God does that.
Third, we need inspiration and encouragement to change the way the world works so that everyone benefits. There will always be risk in living, and many authors have reminded us that without risk, life would be lifeless, boring, maybe even meaningless. What’s the fun of succeeding beyond our wildest dreams if there’s no risk of failure? In the 2000 years since Jesus, God has inspired people to make significant improvements in reducing the risks of life. The people surrounding Jesus that day couldn’t imagine vaccines which eliminate deadly diseases, or modern agriculture that can feed billions. Since that time life has been enriched by art and architecture and music. Science explains many things and questions many more. They were injured by falling towers and we are protected by building codes and stronger materials. They were at the mercy of weather and we have complex warning systems. I’m pretty discouraged these days by what’s broken in our world, and it’s good to remember what isn’t broken. We are the beneficiaries of so much good. Human ingenuity is pretty amazing, and I believe God plays a part in that.
Luke pairs this story with the story of the fig tree. Its owner is angry that it’s not bearing fruit and is ready to get rid of it, but the worker holds out hope. A little cultivation, some well-placed manure – maybe it will do better. Maybe the most important gift of God is hope. There’s a lot of repentance needed from a lot of folks, but there’s still hope. At the same time disaster threatens, there are people who believe in justice, who practice kindness, and who are working every day to create a better world and a more humble community. God is in the heart of that, joining us in the effort. If you want a better world, do justice, love kindness, walk humbly because God walks with us.