Matthew 21:1-11
Palm Sunday is one of my favorite celebrations – and maybe one of yours, too. It’s fun waving palms and shouting Hosanna! This is one of the rare stories found in all four of our gospels, so it must have been a favorite of Jesus’ followers from the beginning.
The story is set in Jerusalem when people are gathering for Passover, a spring festival that celebrates God setting people free from slavery in Egypt. Those who were able to travel were required to be in Jerusalem for Passover, so there would have been thousands of travelers crowding the streets. As they came into the city, they would have been singing verses from the Psalms, like we did today. John tells us that as they gathered, they were wondering if the new prophet from Galilee would show up for the festival.
This is a celebration of freedom observed by people who were occupied and oppressed. They were in a mood for something important to happen in the face of Rome. Jesus is staying with friends in the nearby village of Bethany, and when he comes to the city it’s no surprise that a spontaneous welcome breaks out in the crowd. Matthew quotes scripture to prove that Jesus is coming as the Messiah – reflecting his agenda to prove that to later first-century Jews. Maybe people saw Jesus as a Messiah. They certainly saw him as a challenge to Roman rulers. They were hoping for insurrection. (They never dreamed they’d get resurrection instead.) Surely the positive reaction of the crowd to Jesus’ presence and their attention to his teaching prompted Rome to arrest him and execute him. They too saw him as a threat to the peace, if not to their power.
We’ve talked in other years about the fact that Jesus is portrayed as entering Jerusalem from one direction in peace while Roman soldiers are entering from another direction in a show of military force. The troops are coming to control the crowds about to gather. They don’t want trouble and they have the physical might to squelch any uprisings. I’m pretty sure the contrast between military power and peace was lost on the crowds that day. They wanted an armed uprising that threw off Roman control. They weren’t looking for a theological understanding of the nature of power and the reign of God. Those understandings only come after decades or centuries of reflection. What the story was about on the day it happened and what it means to us two millennia later aren’t the same.
Let’s start with a parade that celebrates Jesus. In the first century that would have been a spontaneous challenge to established power. It would have been a hope for the overthrow of oppressive government and a violent response to the violence of the times. The people celebrating for the most part misunderstood all that Jesus was teaching about peace and love. But they did understand what he was saying about justice and the abuse of power. Their society needed to change, and Jesus represented change, even if they weren’t ready to hear his non-violent teachings.
A parade that celebrates Jesus today wouldn’t be a challenge to power it would celebrate the prominence of Christianity as a force in contemporary life. Some of the conservative churches in our towns are planning a March for Jesus this spring. This march won’t be a challenge to those things in our current society that are unjust and divisive. It will celebrate the values of the Christian right – many of which bear no resemblance to Jesus’ teachings. It will be an endorsement of power and a way of thinking that seeks to control social norms based on a misunderstanding of Jesus’ vision. I suspect it will stand in stark contrast to the first Palm Sunday because it celebrates the way that Christianity has become the Empire.
Next, let’s look at the role of violence in this story. The Psalms quoted suggest that Jesus comes in peace, symbolized by the donkey he rides (which isn’t a war horse). Jesus’ teachings are about peace – turn the other cheek, go the second mile, love your enemy. He wanted to change the way life worked as much as those who advocated revolution, but he wanted to do that in a very different way. He talked about forming community, caring for one another and sharing power for the benefit of everyone. Rome maintained control of society for the benefit of the wealthy through violence, particularly crucifixion and warfare. Centuries later we are still unpacking what nonviolence means and how it can be used to create a better world.
It’s very hard for us to understand how nonviolence and the teachings of Jesus can operate in a world even more visibly at war in this moment. It’s tempting to meet bombs with bombs and death with death. Our world has been attacked – indeed has never been without attacks in one place or another. The current violence in Ukraine is just more visible to us that some of the many other places at war. I have no answers as to what a follower of Jesus would do in response. I do know what Jesus did. He confronted abusive power and called it out for what it is. He encouraged people to live from a core of love and compassion. That’s incredibly hard.
Russia is by no means the only aggressor in our moment in history. While we name aloud their actions, we also need to name the ways in which we too participate in the abuse of power and in violence toward others. Sometimes that’s military violence, but it’s also economic and racial. It has to do with the distribution of wealth and the opening of opportunity, with available food and health care and education. It has to do with how we live within our country and as leaders in a complicated world.
Our time in history feels more complicated to us than the first century, maybe because we’re living in the thick of it and lack the perspective of time. So the lessons we learn from Palm Sunday are also more complicated. They tell us to celebrate – who Jesus is and what he teaches us to do and to be. Celebrations matter. We can embrace them. At the same time, we celebrate not because Jesus eventually won and we benefit from being on top. We celebrate because we too stand at a moment when change is both badly needed and possible. Like our spiritual ancestors we hope that Jesus brings something different, and we don’t yet understand what that is. We want God’s vision to be in control of the world and we aren’t quite sure how to make that happen.
This week Katanji Brown Jackson was confirmed as the next Supreme Court justice. The hearings around her approval demonstrated the progress of our nation and the great distance we still have to go. She represents a milestone in justice and freedom and the fact that we aren’t yet on the same page. She represents possibility. We are celebrating what has happened, even as we clarify what still needs to come. It’s a good example of what it means to celebrate a Palm Sunday moment. Blessed is the One who comes in the name of the Lord. Now that we see him among us, what will we do next?